The census by definition is for people WHO LIVE in a country where it’s conducted, but apparently that’s not the case in Australia where they even make it mandatory for non-citizens (tourists) when they are only visitors (who DO NOT live in Australia in the first place), the logic doesn’t make any sense. Like if, a tourist should not be forced to do it since they hold a foreign passport and have no residential address in Australia.

  • Nath@aussie.zoneM
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    15 days ago

    It was an example. A simple data point anyone could understand. But as I haven’t convinced you yet, let’s take it further…

    What of the three-year-old population in Kensington? They aren’t at the school yet but will want to be next year. Or the couples in their late 20’s who are married? Several of those will want to send kids in ~5 years. How will you learn how many of those are in the area?

    town planners would conduct a thorough review and actually ask stakeholders, like local residents, parents, other schools, etcetera.

    Sure would be useful for those town planners to have some useful statistical demographics from the last five years to refer to for this review, wouldn’t it? What if they had multiple snapshots of Kensington every five years over the last 20 years or so? That data would be super useful for conducting a review. They should do a survey of the people in Kensington to get that data!

    • im_fine_sandy@nord.pub
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      15 days ago

      Oh man.

      What if the school had some data like… Oh I don’t know… The number of enrolments of 4 year olds for the last n years. That would certainly be an interesting data point.

      It just doesn’t make any sense to me at all to suggest that people are making these decisions with census data.

      State education departments don’t have surplus funds. There are no schools sitting empty because someone is waiting for the census to tell them there are no students in the area. Likewise there are no schools being built because the census says there are some 3 year olds I’m the area.

      Education departments allocate their scarce resources based on enrolments. That’s it.

      Seriously, this is truly the dumbest example.